Hermione and the Boggart/ Sibling theory

twodrink.ange twodrink.ange at yahoo.co.uk
Tue Jun 12 21:45:32 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 170215

> Nikkalmati
>
> I don't think Harry and Hermione will turn out to be twins or
siblings,
> because that result would destroy the Mudbloods are as good as any
other wizard
> theme.  It would support the pureblood supremacy theory by making
Hermione  a
> half-blood, not Muggleborn, and explain her power as deriving from
James and
> Lily.  I do believe canon supports the idea that most people have
wizards  in
> their background somewhere, but I don't think it will turn out
Hermione has
> wizards as close relatives (that goes for Lily too).
> >
>


I think its something more spiritual between the two. There is a
connection there which is why a lot of people have pondered the
sibling theory. I don't think they are blood related simply because
of the blood supremacy themes in the book. The reasons you have given
make more sense in the overall big picture which is why i didn't
think that is the route J.K would take.
 There is a lot of emphasis on death and the spiritual world in the
books re the Veil. Harry and Hermione represent platonic love which
will be needed in the final book. With alchemy, a theory that seems
to make sense, there is an emphasis on twin flame. People don't have
to be blood related to have an intense connection. Together their
strenghts combined make them a formidable patnership. They are each
others equal which could be used in some way. They represent the
masculine, feminine psyche. Opposites. Pagan religion is very much
about equality between the two.

Hermione is more aware perhaps of the bond at the moment which is why
she has risked so much. There are hints in the book about Ancient
runes and patnership. It could all be to do with the soul's journey
and how some souls are destined to travel through life with each
other.
J K originally had the two of them with the initials but changed
Hermione's surname. If they are not blood related then this could
have been a clue to the soul mate theory.

Roll on July, the theories are great but the not knowing is getting a
little frustrating! :)

twodrink.ange




More information about the HPforGrownups archive