Justice to Snape WAS: Re: Werewolves? There Wolves!

[pippin_999]

No: HPFGUIDX 170549


> Alla:

> 
> I think Mike just meant a general justice being carried out towards 
> Snape dear, and as you know I also think that Snape did not 
> experience any sort of justice yet. Hopefully he will.
> 
> He delivers prophecy to Voldemort and two young people die and one 
> boy remains an orphan – does he get punished for that? Not as far as 
> I know. On the contrary, he comes back to Dumbledore and supposedly 
> tells him how **sorry** he was  and instead of Azkaban he gets a nice 
> job as Hogwarts professor – food, shelter, protection and all that.

Pippin:
Um, what about the part where he turned spy for the Order at
great personal risk? Are you saying that if he had been a careless
spy and gotten himself killed it would have been just, 
but since he was a good spy and stayed alive so he could keep 
supplying the Order with information, it was a slap on the wrist?

IOW, Dumbledore should  have sent him on a suicide mission?
I don't think so.
 
Pippin