More evidence for DDM!Snape

[colebiancardi]

No: HPFGUIDX 170605

 
> "alcuin74" <alcuin74@> wrote:
> 
> > We're told that there are three shapes
> > in the foe glass just before DD blasts
> > the door open and stuns Imposter Moody,
> > one shape corresponding to each of DD,
> > McGonagall and Snape. 
> 
> eggplant wrote:
> But in the very next book Harry tells the members of the DA not to
> rely of a foe glass too much because it can be fooled. And there is
> absolutely no doubt Snape is very good at fooling people; for 15 years
> Snape has fooled Voldemort or Dumbledore or both. If he can fool
> wizards like that I think he could fool a foe glass.


colebiancardi:

but where did Harry get that information from?  Is that just his own
"opinion" or fact?  If his "opinion", it is biased, IMHO

Also, I have always wondered about the foe glass - is it showing the
true enemies of the owner of said glass or the perceived enemies (they
think they are, but they truly aren't).  Does the foe glass work off
of true ownership - which begs the question, did Moody's foe glass
belong to the Fake!Moody or the Real!Moody?

colebiancardi