More evidence for DDM!Snape

[Dana]

No: HPFGUIDX 170613

Alcuin: 
<snip>
> We're told that there are three 
> shapes in the foe glass just before DD blasts the door open and 
> stuns Imposter Moody, one shape corresponding to each of DD, 
> McGonagall and Snape.  I'm assuming that Imposter Moody "tweaked" 
> the foe glass so that his enemies, i.e., enemies of a Death Eater 
> or enemies of the Dark Side, would show up in the glass, which 
> makes sense of DD and McGonagall doing so.  It also makes sense of 
> Snape doing so *if and only if he is on the side of the Order*.  If 
> you re-read that scene, JKR seems to make it a point to mention a 
> second time that Snape is seen in the foe glass, and this time she 
> mentions him specifically.
<snip>

Dana:
Well there is a slight problem with the Foe Glass being used to proof 
DDM!Snape. If the Foe glass would show enemies of the Dark Side then 
there is one person in that room that isn't reflected in it while it 
should. Harry indeed. He is an enemy, the only one that is 
prophesized to be able to vanquish the Dark Lord so he surely should 
have been visible in the Glass if it indeed showed enemies of the 
Dark Side. So it actually does not show this unless anyone wants to 
suggest that Harry is actually a Dark Wizard himself. 

The Foe Glass is indeed tweaked because otherwise it would only show 
the real Moody's enemies. DD and McGonagall are surely not (I do not 
mention Snape because the real Moody does not trust Snape if we go by 
what we saw in the pensieve). So to be honest with you the Foe Glass 
is in my opinion a pretty clever red-herring because it actually only 
reflects Barty Jr's enemies and this includes Snape, not only because 
Snape is still working with DD and is thought to have left LV forever 
but also because Barty hates those that denounced LV after his down 
fall. He hates them so much that he actually wanted to attack them at 
the Quidditch World Cup but Winky prevented this. 

JMHO

Dana