Harry an accidental Horcrux??

[Geoff Bannister]

No: HPFGUIDX 170639

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Tandra" <tkjones9 at ...> wrote:
>
> I know, I know people feel this has been discussed to death, but I had
> to toss my hat in the ring....
> 
> Let me try to verify my accidental making, though I know people think
> it isn't possible because Slughorn said it takes a complicated piece
> of magic to make one and so forth. But with Harry, and LV we are
> dealing with magic that no one has seen. It basica;;y becomes a
> guessing game for DD as he tries to figure out all the characteristics
> of Harry's scar or what happened. 
> 
> So what's to say that if an AK is reflected that the person who cast
> it doesn't lose a piece of their soul in the process. Maybe passing it
> onto Harry through the scar very untintentionally. Isn't there a
> theory that he entered the house with the intent to make his last
> Horocrux anyway, so what's to say he hadn't already started said
> complicated process before he got to the house and it was somehow
> completed when the AK failed. 
> 
> Ok I've babbled on long enough...Feel free to tear it apart now.

Geoff:
A quick thought.

If, as you suggest, he had possibly already started the 
process, it should be remembered that he did kill two 
people in advance of his attempt on Harry and if his
intent was to kill Harry, so why would he be "assembling" 
the Horcrux spell for use that night...