Harry an accidental Horcrux??

[ohnooboe]

No: HPFGUIDX 170660

SNNNIP!!
 jr_pumpkin:

it seems to me that Harry cannot contain a part of Voldy's soul, since 
it would be agonizing to him to coexist with it.  He would be in a 
constant state of burning, agony, pain, etc. because the 'good' from 
Lily's sacrifice would be constantly warring with the evil of Voldemort.


ohnooboe says:

I think that's a really good point.  Frankly, I think the Harry is a 
Horcrux is silly (god help me if it really is the case...) but this is 
a good way to explain the theory away.  LV had a hard time possessing 
Harry for just a short time in OOTP, I can't imagine that a piece of 
his soul could exist for 17 years inside Harry without being 
destroyed.  

PM