Dumbledore's Fall

[barb burke]

No: HPFGUIDX 170831

There's no doubt in my mind that Snape did what
Dumbledore wanted him to do whether or not it was 
planned for. When Dumbledore saw what was happenning
on the tower he was in his right mind and doing his
best to convince Drago to come over to the right side{
and doing a good job of convincing him}  when the DEs
burst on to the tower . At that point Dumbledore knew
they were up the creek and then Severus came on the
scene and in a silent exchange between the two , we
see the final outcome. There was no begging on the
part of Dumbledore {that just rings so false that it
doesn't ever bare thinking about , knowing what we do
of Dumbledore....does anyone even for a second believe
that he would beg?} SO,in that silent exchange between
the two Severus is made aware of what he must do and ,
does what Dumbledore wants him to, not do what
is "easy" In my opinion,of course.


squeaker19450