How Will It End - Predictions from Keith Olbermann/ Harry giving up his magi
dumbledore11214
dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Thu Jun 28 19:23:33 UTC 2007
No: HPFGUIDX 170946
>> Sandy:
<SNIP>
> I like Keith so I am thrilled to find out he is a Potter fan. As
for his
> predictions: I, personally, do not believe Harry's scar is a
Horcrux, so I
> obviously can't go along with his prediction completely. However,
Harry giving up
> his magical powers, that mean so much to him, would be a very big
sacrifice,
> and a fit ending rather than having him die. It's a sound theory,
but I can't
> say I like it. I don't want to see Harry give up his powers,
although I would
> rather see that than his death.
<SNIP>
Alla:
I was pretty sure I read this quote from JKR, but now I cannot find
it, so maybe somebody could help me.
I am also pretty sure that this was a 2006 interview, just do not
know which one.
Unless I am majorly confused, I seem to remember that interviewer
asked her about this ending , whether it is likely to happen that
Harry will give up his magic at the end, or something to this effect.
I also seem to remember that the answer was that this is a good
ending, but she does not want to be sued for stealing it from
fanfiction or something like that.
Again, that is my vague recollection, I can be completely wrong, but
I also was thinking that it debunked the "Harry gives up his magic at
the end" ending completely in my mind.
Alla.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive