Ollivander's Disappearance/brother wands/other predictions

colebiancardi muellem at bc.edu
Thu Jun 28 23:48:41 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 170963

 
> Colwilrin wrote:
<snip>
> One last wild thought. What if Snape and Lily were related
> through the muggle side. That is why she stuck up for him,
> her weird distant cousin. Snape would be upset with Voldy
> killing his "family".  This would also give Harry one very
> surprising male relative in the end...that he might just
> look up to when Snape is revealed as DDM.  I would really
> love to see Harry have one remaining live relative at the
> end...<snip>
> 

colebiancardi:

a few years ago, I thought of this - that Snape & Lily had a
relationship, not as "lovers" or "unrequited" love stuff, but as
family relations - that they were distant cousins.

However, DD stated that Petunia was Harry's last living relative - in
OotP, he tells Harry "I put my trust, therefore, in your mother's
blood.  I delivered you to her sister, her only remaining relative" p
836, Am Ed Hardcover

So, I don't think, although I love the idea, that Snape is Harry's
distant second or third cousin removed....on ***his mother's side***

However, what about James?  Did he have any relatives?  Could Snape be
his cousin, several times removed?  I don't remember anything about
James' family, other than his parents were "older" and that they
weren't living anymore.  Could he have had someone in his family tree
that branched out and married a muggle?  Are we sure that Eileen
Prince is a pure-blood?  She might be a half-blood, like Snape.   Yes,
I know that Snape calls himself half-blood Prince, but his mum was a
witch and his dad was a muggle - so, in a way, it is still
"half-blood".  Any thoughts?  Any one with a better memory remember
the story behind James and relatives?


>Colwilrin:
> Got Crow?

colebiancardi:
yep, and I am hoping to release him on July 21st or thereabouts :)






More information about the HPforGrownups archive