Who Loved Snape? WAS: Re: FOR DISCUSSION: Ultimate and Last

[Eddie]

No: HPFGUIDX 171022

> zgirnius:
> Well, let's take a quick look at 
> the people Snape has harmed, and see who among them might have loved 
> Snape.
> 
> 1) ... Assorted students he has abused as a teacher. ...
> 2) Harry ...
> 3) James Potter. ...
> 4) Sirius and Peter. ...
> 5) Remus. ...
> 6) Albus. ...
> 7) Nameless possible victims of Death Eater crimes ...
> 8) Assorted Death Eaters he may have betrayed ...
>
> Which brings me to the final person on my list (I hope I am not 
> forgetting some supposed crime or other of the former Potions master):
> 
> 9) Lily Evans Potter ...

Eddie:
Let's not forget Snape's mother.  Remember the memory that Harry saw
in OOTP, Chapter 26 "Seen and Unforeseen": the "hooknosed man was
shouting at a cowering woman, while a small darkhaired boy cried in a
corner
"  This is presumably Snape and his mother (who presumably
loved him).

Eddie, who maybe should have predicted Snape's boggart was the
hook-nosed man.  Darn.