The green liquid in the basin
Goddlefrood
gav_fiji at yahoo.com
Sat Mar 3 04:27:29 UTC 2007
No: HPFGUIDX 165645
> Paul
> How did the basin get refilled? If the basin had been emptied before,
by whoever took the horcrux, it should have still been empty. Is the
basin enchanted, so that it refills itself when emptied? If not, who
refilled it? Food for thought.
Goddlefrood:
Welcome Paul. Ask yourself this - if the original locket Horcrux was
removed from the basin, do you not think it likely that as well as
place a dummy locket therein that person would have refilled the basin?
What I find most interesting relative to the potion in the basin is to
wonder whether or not the potion that was there when Dumbledore and
Harry arrived on the scene was the same as what was there when the
original protection of the Horcrux was set up.
OTOH it could be possible that the basin refills itself as suggested,
but I like the idea that R. A. B. actually refilled the basin with a
different potion altogether.
Humbly submitted
Goddlefrood, who hopes Yahoo!Mort won't take three hours to put this
message through like my previous and also that it does not get
reformatted ditto.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive