Where is Dumbledore's wand?
Goddlefrood
gav_fiji at yahoo.com
Wed Mar 7 11:52:06 UTC 2007
No: HPFGUIDX 165803
> > Bercygirl2 asked:
> > During the events on the tower, Dumbledore was disarmed and his
> > wand thrown off. Does anyone have any thoughts about where it
> > could be now?
> > It doesn't seem likely to me that it was just left lying in the
> > grass.
<SNIP>
> Funkeginger answered (in part):
> I dont think it was burned with DD or they would have said
> something in book HBP.
Goddlefrood (with a small aside):
Like JKR remembered about the Marauder's Map in book 4, then?
> Funkeginger then continued:
<SNIP>
> What if V was trying to use him to find a way out of the bond he
> and Harry share as far as the wands go?
Goddlefrood:
Who is this V of whom you speak? A new character on me I'm afraid.
Sorry, LV, huh?
Anyway, perhaps you might care to expand on just why DD's wand would
be important as suggested. Do you, perhaps, think that LV will get
and use DD's wand to counteract the Priori Incantatem effect?
If he did, I hope that it backfires, now there's a thought... (The
Magnificent Backfiring Wand theory - a work in progress) :)
> Funky Chicken (apologies Ginger):
> Last but not least, didn't Malfoy carry DD's wand when he was
fleeing the Tower? Maybe he took it to You Know Who.
Goddlefrood:
No, he didn't. Here's what the relevant canon says (Bloomsbury
Hardback Edition - The Lightning Struck Tower, pps. 545-6):
"Then by the light of the Mark, he saw Dumbledore's wand flying in an
arc *over the edge of the ramparts* and understood ... Dumbledore had
wordlessly immobilised Harry, and the second he had taken to mperform
the spell had cost him the chance of defending himself."
I couldn't see any other later reference to the wand , but it's
clear it flew off the Tower, so unless Draco took another detour, he
can't have it and won't, therefore, be giving it to LV. Do feel free
to point me to any you (generic) may come across.
Having said this DD's wand will probably be of little further
significance
IMO.
Goddlefrood
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive