That whole locket, green goo in mysterious cave thing (was: gree

[colebiancardi]

No: HPFGUIDX 165824

 "Debi" <dobbycat at ...> wrote:
>
> What am I missing? Where does it say in HBP that Bellatrix was the
one to place the locket in the cave? Or where does it say she had it
in the first place, page or chapter? Because I can't find this reference.
> 
 

colebiancardi:

It doesn't state it anywhere.  It is a theory - just like all of the
theories on this board.  We try to base our theories on hints in the
books - The reason why I think this is a good theory is because of
this line in HBP spoken by Bellatrix: "The Dark Lord has, in the past,
entrusted me with his most precious..." HBP Am Edition hardback -
"Spinner's End" pg 29.  Put that with the theory that RAB is Regulus
Black, who was a DE that turned and was *killed* (still thinking that
Regulus is alive), and that Bellatrix is Regulus's cousin - it makes
for a pretty good theory.

That Bellatrix had the locket - Regulus took it and replaced it with
the fake one.  Or something along those lines.  

colebiancardi
(this board is full of theories - some sadly gone by the wayside, some
happily gone by the wayside and some still unknown until book 7 - and
even then, maybe never known)