The Green Goo Again - lockets confusion

[zanooda2]

No: HPFGUIDX 165836

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "snow15145" <kking0731 at ...> wrote:

> Then why did the locket from Dumbledore's pocket appear different to 
> Harry immediately from the one he vaguely remembered seeing when 
> Dumbledore took it from the basin in the cave?


I'm confused! I've always thought that Harry noticed the difference 
between the fake locket that fell from DD's pocket and the real 
Slytherin's locket that he (Harry) saw in the Pensieve, in Ogden's 
memory, not the difference between the locket from DD's pocket and the 
locket DD took from the basin (I still think it's the same locket, but 
this is not the point). 

Harry  didn't even look at the locket when DD took it from the basin, 
IIRC, and he barely caught a glimpse of it in the basin. I don't think 
he could notice any difference even if it existed. All he could see was 
that the locket from DD's pocket was not Slytherin's locket that Harry 
saw Merope wearing in Ogden's memory.

That's how I've always understood it. Maybe I missed something here. I 
just don't think that Harry would call the basin in the cave "Pensieve" 
even if they look similar (p.609 US).


zanooda, confused