Details of the "Prank" (WAS Re: LV's bigger plan (was:Fawkes possible absence))

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 166340

> Dana:
> > Another is of course where were the others? They are supposed to 
be
> > running with Lupin every month.
> 
> zgirnius:
> There could be some reason they were not going that night (I 
dunno, 
> Peter or Sirius had a cold or something...), or Snape could have 
> showed up before the Marauders. It does not seem a detail that 
> renders the story we have been told in any way problematic.
>

Alla:

Heee, problematic? Don't know. Adds another questions and suspicions?

To me for sure. They are absent the night of the Prank and no other 
night? How could that be? What happened? Who told James what is 
happening?

What was Peter doing? 

And do you realise the implications of your speculation that Snape 
showed up before Marauders?

That can mean to me another potential support in favor of Snape 
figuring out **before** hand that Remus was a werewolf and going in 
for the kill, thus also somehow managing to keep James occupied 
somehow.

Oy, what would I have give up to read what happened that night 
**now**.

Please JKR, pretty please, you promised to tell us:)

Alla