LV's bigger plan / Trelawney at the funeral or not?
Dana
ida3 at planet.nl
Sat Mar 24 20:31:40 UTC 2007
No: HPFGUIDX 166426
<snip>
houyhnhnm:
> If she *has* a memory. I'm not sure she does.
> Trelawney doesn't have any conscious memory of either
> of the true prophecies she has made. Perhaps she is
> only a conduit. Her case is different, therefore,
> from that of Bertha Jorkins.
Dana:
I do not agree that even though she herself cannot remember it
consciously that this would mean the memory would not be there.
We have seen in the several pensieve scenes that a memory can be looked
at from a perspective that the owner of that memory would not have been aware of at the time the memory registered in the mind. Her mere presence in the room would make it possible to look at the scene from a third person's view and hear her tell DD the prophecy.
Dana
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive