Ootp movie changes--effect on DH--ALLOWED?

rtbthw_mom dossett at lds.net
Wed Mar 28 00:13:50 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 166529

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "julie" <juli17 at ...> wrote:
>
> If we want to discuss the differences (additions/deletions)
> between the Ootp movie and novel, and what the changes might
> possibly tell us about the upcoming DH novel, would that be
> allowed here? I know the movies aren't to be discussed here
> in general, but if the discussion pertains directly to what
> may happen in DH, that seems a gray area to me, and I didn't
> want to post anything without knowing for sure. If it is 
> allowed, presumably SPOILER would be required in the subject
> header in regards to the movie.
> 
> Thanks, 
> Julie
>
Pat now -
I agree.  I am currently rereading OotP and I've been wondering which
parts they'll have to leave out - the movie can't be four hours long!
 And that directly affects DH: for instance, the scenes with Grawp, I
wouldn't mind if they were cut, but will Grawp be important in DH, and
if so, in what way?  I wonder if he could be important if Steve's
battle at Hogwarts comes to pass?  

I have other comments, but I'll wait to see what the list elves have
to say about this.  

Thanks -
Pat





More information about the HPforGrownups archive