Maraurders/he exists

Hagrid aussie_lol at yahoo.com.au
Wed May 2 07:28:35 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 168235

--- "justcarol67" wrote:

> on James can't be Sectumsempra. He is not "cut always." ...
> There's no indication that he's even still
> bleeding as he speaks to Lily.)  
> 
Aussie:
I agree. The "sempra" part is "always". So the spell in the memory 
was the little brother of "Sectumsempra".

But was that ... and for that matter ... all the notaions in the 
Potions book from young Severus? Why not from his dear sweet mother?

Lupin suggested to check the edition's date and worked out it pre-
dated Severus. It would have been Elaine's and many of the notaions 
hers as well.

I seem to remember someone saying Snape came to Hogwarts knowing 
more Dark spells than most older kids. His mummy must have been 
quite a Dark Teacher herself.

Getting back to Sectumsempra, what enemies was that for? for the 
werewolf? ... Snape still had the Potions book in the cabinet, so 
may have refered to and added notations through the years .. not 
just in his 6th year at Hogwarts.
---------------------------
And about the Map being Dark ... what if the Map was one of the few 
good things that Pettigrew could do? It may have been Peter's Dark 
Journey.

I think this because some areas don't show on the map 
- Hagrid's Hut (since Peter could hide there undetected)
- Room of Requirements (since Draco disappeared off the map)
- Chamber of Secrets (the twins would have searched for Ginny and 
not found her)

To plot places on the map, the drawer has to be there to add it in. 
So how come Slytherin's Common Room shows up? Could the Rat have 
sneaked in?

If the Map was mainly Peter's doing and was truely Dark, I wonder 
when Peter started his course towards the Dark side (oops, Did i 
just use a line from Star Wars?)

Aussie





More information about the HPforGrownups archive