Maraurders/he exists

[rlace2003]

No: HPFGUIDX 168294

> Alla:
<SNIPPED>
> The major flaw I see in the parallel that you developed is that
> that several people brought up the reasoning why pensieve scene
> may not turn out to be all that reliable.

> I think that there would be far more *understandable* reasons
> for that attack than attack by Dudley, but I can be wrong.

Ryan:

In what sense could the pensieve scene be unreliable?

I actually hadn't considered the parallels Dudley/James parallels
before.  It does make sense, though.  Harry must've hated having
to sypmathize with Snape in that situation.