The REAL Spy

Phyllis D. (P. D.) Barnes phyllisdbarnes at comcast.net
Fri May 4 17:46:14 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 168336

Kim...
> > shooting in the dark in a vain attempt to clear McGonagall of any
suspicion whatsoever.

Anne Squires:
> Also, the traitor in GOF is Barty Crouch Jr. who does not not have
> alliterative initials.

Phyllis:
I agree the spy won't be McGonagall. In all the books we've only
seen DE's use the Unforgiveable curses - - the spy could be Delores
Umbridge. She's a high-level ministry official and a member of the
Wizengamot and thus has access to a lot of information that Voldy would
find useful. She also showed a knowledge of and willingness to use
the Cruciatus Curse - - which Bella taught us takes more than mere
outrage to the words to actually perform.




More information about the HPforGrownups archive