SQUEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE - JKR updated website ;) Spoilers? Maybe?
sistermagpie
belviso at attglobal.net
Tue May 8 20:06:22 UTC 2007
No: HPFGUIDX 168435
Alla:
> And where it matters not the less, to me anyways :)
>
> She answered some canon questions. Now if I had **any** doubts
that she
> is going for sobbing story with Draco Malfoy, I have none anymore,
hehe.
>
> Poor dear could not produce Patronus before HBP, tee hee. But even
this
> she answered in a tricky way, IMO.
>
> Can he not produce because he is not good enough or because he did
not
> have any happy memories?
Magpie:
Err...neither as far as we know. She said that as of the end of HBP
Draco has no idea how to produce a Patronus--just like most every
other kid at Hogwarts (except those who got privately taught, such
as Harry and the DA)--because that spell isn't taught in school. So
it's not really a spoiler--Draco had never been taught about
Patronuses as far as we know. It doesn't necessarily indicate he's
got to ultimately have a sad story or not. Harry's already been
lauded for his talent in producing a Patronus in OotP (though others
in the DA can also produce one by then). But Draco has not been
thoroughly judged and found inadequate in that particular answer.
It's the same as if she'd been asked what Draco saw in the Mirror of
Erised and she said he'd never looked into it so nobody knows.
I may be being too optimistic myself, but I thought she was
potentially trickier on the question of Draco's wand. I had, like
the questioner, assumed Hawthorn to begin with for the month (plus
it seemed to fit). She was asked his wand qualities and only gave
the wood, with the story of how she'd chosen his, like Harry's, for
the personal characteristics and then discovered she'd chosen the
wood associated with his birthday in the Celtic chart. So she left
out the core, which is part of the wand description. But that might
mean nothing.
-m
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive