Snape as expert on Harry's home life WAS: Re: Snape as Neville's teacher

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 168476

Lupinlore:
<SNIP>

> Now, the other question, though, is WHY Snape would have felt he had a
> rational reason?  What does he know about Harry and his life?  What
> does he suspect?  <SNIP>


Alla:

Well, if Snape **knows** about Harry home life, he is just flat out 
evil, IMO, because he presents Harry as celebrity who is enjoying it 
when he knows that neither Harry has anything close to celebrity 
treatment at home and neither does he enjoy it.

If Snape does not know about Harry's home life, then he is just a 
presumptious ass, I think. Heeee, interesting symmetry with UV, me 
thinks :)

If Snape knows the task, with information we have he looks evil to me ( 
IMO of course, if he does not know about the task, he is a presumptious 
idiot IMO of course.

Hmmm, loose analogy of course, but may work for me. Have to sit on it.

Alla.