Quick Questionnaire

[pippin_999]

No: HPFGUIDX 168559

> A quick questionnaire for you:
> Sirius Black "had to die" (according to JKR) to:
> 
> 
> e) Keep ESE!Lupin's cover – Sirius had begun to find Lupin's 
> behaviour a bit suspect, so the werewolf had him silenced.
> 

Pippin:
Actually I don't think Sirius was suspicious. What got Sirius
killed, according to ESE!Lupin theory,  was knowing too much. 

"Harry, take the prophecy, grab Neville, and run!"   

Why is the prophecy mentioned, except to inform us
that Sirius knew? And how does he know? Anyone who
knew the true significance of the Prophecy in Dumbledore's
eyes, ie, not much, would never have asked either Harry
or Neville to risk their lives for it. But if Lupin let something
slip to Sirius, thinking that Harry would have told him already, 
then Lupin would have had some explaining to do if Sirius had
lived.

Maybe some of the tension between Sirius and Dumbledore was
because Sirius thought Dumbledore had told Lupin about the
prophecy and not him?

Pippin