Quick Questionnaire v1.1

[Shaunette Reid]

No: HPFGUIDX 168621

> Dungrollin: 
(huge snip)
> An echo which retained Cedric's appearance and character, the way 
the 
> magnetic tape in a cassette retains a voice's rhythm, pitch and so 
> on, *but is not the actual person, nor their soul nor spirit*. I 
> think that crossing the veil and seeing Sirius *would* be different 
> to seeing a portrait or a priori incantatem echo, or a ghost (which 
> are the imprints of departed souls, but not the souls themselves). 
(more snipping)

Shaunette:
I realize this is a tiny part of the points made in Dungrollin's post, 
just wondering why a ghost is not considered the soul itself? I was 
under the impression that ghosts are the souls of those who are too 
afraid to "let go" and cross over to the other side, as explained by 
NHNick?