Why did JKR not explore H/Hr as canon?

honeypi28 honeypi28 at yahoo.com
Sun May 13 16:18:47 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 168658


nirjhar.jain:

> I am baffled as to the reason why Jo Rowling did not explore H/Hr as a
> ship?
> 
> Hermione is Harry's equal intellectually. She stands upto him. She is
> not overawed by him.

honeypi:

It's a bit early to say H/Hr won't be cannon.  I think Harry's relationship with Hermione is 
so well developed and complex that she is likely his true love and will have a large role in 
LV's demise.  I know a lot of people disagree, but I'd be disappointed if the person whom I 
believe loves Harry the most doesn't turn out to be 'the one' for him.  I suspect JKR is 
waiting until the end to reveal this pairing to emphasize it's significance and elevate it 
above the prerequisite teen puppy love we've seen so far.

nirjhar.jain:

> I love Ron as a character. I just think he is too shallow and an
> intellectual light-weight compared to Hermione.

honeypi:

Ron is hilarious.  He's the 'fun guy' and represents a carefree spirit that no doubt seems 
attractive to a youthful Hermione who is very much on the opposite end of the spectrum.  I 
think it's typical of teens to look at all of their peers and learn what types compliment 
them best.  I don't see Ron and Hermione as a viable pairing because he'd (or I guess she 
would) have to change too dramatically to really be even matched with her.  I like Ron as 
he is, so I'd hate to see that happen.  

Of course, I haven't analyzed the books so well as many others here.  These are simply my 
impressions from a few casual readings of the books.  I look forward to reading more 
informed opinions.

honeypi






More information about the HPforGrownups archive