Why did JKR not explore H/Hr as canon?
colebiancardi
muellem at bc.edu
Sun May 13 23:02:13 UTC 2007
No: HPFGUIDX 168667
> Miles:
> I agree. But let's see...
> "I think that if she and Ron were together, she might become a
nagger. Ron
> does not like being organised by /anyone/ and I feel that any such
> relationship would come under severe strain."
> <snip>
> Hermione seems to be the kind of girl/woman who wants to create her
partner,
> and she works on Ron from the very beginning of PS/SS. But will she
be ever
> satisfied with the Ron she might create?
> And Ron - will he really tolerate being dominated the way Hermione
will try
> to dominate any partner she has?
> And - what do have Hermione and Ron in common apart from Hogwarts?
Hobbies?
> Concepts of life? Ambitions? Past? Future?
>
colebiancardi:
ahhh, but how does that old saying go? A boy will marry his mother?
I see a lot of Molly in Hermione and I see a lot of the relationship
in Arthur & Molly and Ron & Hermoine. I don't think Hermione will
dominate Ron over his will. I give a lot of credit to Ron for
standing up to his own beliefs(as Arthur does to Molly). Ron just
choses what battles he will fight with Hermione. It doesn't make him
weak at all. I don't "see" Hermione "working" on Ron; she may push
him to do better, but she doesn't expect anything that is out of Ron's
character.
I've seen the Ron & Hermione romance from CoS, when Ron tried to
defend Hermione's honor when Draco insulted her. What do Ron &
Hermione have in common outside of Hogwarts? Well, call me a
romantic, but it is their love for one another. Sure, they bicker,
but a lot of happy couples bicker - for some, it is a way of "foreplay".
colebiancardi
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive