Why did JKR not explore H/Hr as canon?.

eggplant107 eggplant107 at hotmail.com
Mon May 14 19:50:12 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 168708

"honeypi28" <honeypi28 at ...> wrote:

> Ron's place in the trio is very much
secure at this point.  

It's clear that Ron is in love with Hermione, if Harry were to steal
her away from him the trio would be dead. And even if he wasn't in
love with her he'd still be the odd man out; as it is Ron's the junior
member of the trio, a Harry Hermione relationship would reduce Ron to
a buffoon, nothing more than comic relief. Ron deserves better.
  
> I don't think Harry's in love with Ginny
> either. Maybe I missed that declaration 

In fan fiction when 2 characters fall in love we readers have to
endure long sickly soliloquies where they express their undying love
for each. In contrast Rowling's characters don't talk about how much
they love each other, they show it. 

> I wish JKR had written Ginny as a more likable
> character if she is to be 'the one' for him. 

Off the top of my head I can't remember anything she did that was
particularly unlikable. 

> She's an absolute nightmare in HBP 

Now hold on, I know I would remember it if Ginny had done anything
THAT bad! Well OK, she did lose her temper and said some mean things
to Ron, but she was provoked and had ever reason to be angry with her
brother, she did not fire the first shot , Ron did. Besides it's
traditional for brothers and sisters to have little spats. 

> JKR has room to go in any direction with the ships 

I think the question was settled way back in book 4.

Eggplant






More information about the HPforGrownups archive