[HPforGrownups] Re:Scabbers and LV

[OctobersChild48 at aol.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 168746

houyhnhnm:
Off on a tangent related to the above only as something  
that is not spelled out in the books but which must have 
significance if  one really thinks about it: Scabbers was 
a party to just about every private  conversation between 
Ron and Harry from the time they met on the Hogwarts  Express 
until his faked death at the hands of Crookshanks. How
much of  that information did he pass on to LV and is any 
of it relevant to the  mysteries waiting to be resolved in DH? 


Sandy:
This thought has always bothered me as well. It is only common  sense to 
believe that Voldemort is going to want Peter to tell him everything he  knows 
about Harry, knowing that Peter, as Scabbers, has just spent the better  part of 
three years in close contact with Harry. And if Voldy wants to know  Peter is 
going to tell. The key word is relevant. I don't know the books by  heart like 
so many of the list members do, so I just can't remember if Harry and  Ron 
discussed anything that was relevant to Voldy in front of Scabbers. I would  
also think that Peter, through Harry and Ron, could have some juicy tidbits to  
tell about Snape too. I have always found it to be very disturbing that 
Scabbers  spent so much time with Harry when he turned out to be Peter, a spy and the 
one  responsible for betraying the Potters.
 
Sandy



************************************** See what's free at http://www.aol.com.


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]