Harry can still contact dumbledore ?

jmwcfo jmwcfo at yahoo.com
Wed May 16 03:57:19 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 168803

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Laurel Coates" 
<laurel.coates at ...> wrote:
>
> JW:
> 
> <snip>
> I predict there could be as many
> as three methods to accomplish this [communication with living 
folks]:
> 
> 1. The portrait, although the amount of hard information offered by
> portraits is quite limited.
> 
> 2. Via the pensieve - not as a dialogue, but as a presentation of
> bottled memories DD stored for such a purpose.
> 
> 3. Time travel - DD had a very strange watch. Many fans are
> convinced it was a time control device. If so, then while alive he
> could have travelled forward in time to a future point that takes
> place after his death. For example, he might show up at Bill &
> Fleur's wedding, or at GH shortly afterward.
> 
> Laurel:
> 
> I don't think that watch is a time traveler. Didn't Ron get a 
similar one
> for his 17th birthday?  It seems unlikely that something that 
valuable, and
> probably restricted, would be available so easily. I do hope we get 
an
> answer of what that watch actually does, though. I think it is more 
like a
> weather/star/time forecaster rather than just a plain timepiece.
> 
> Laurel, popping out from lurkdom


JW:
Maybe, maybe not... only time will tell, so to speak.

I recall the gift to Ron.  Who was the giver?  And how does it work? 
With its bizarre configuration, does it even tell time?  And think of 
it - soooo unique, yet now there are two of them? Go back to DD's 
last scenes in the cave and on the tower.  Any mention of his watch? 
Such an unusual instrument, such a detailed description, but no 
explanations... yet.  I recall a very unusual gift HP once received, 
without much explanation - turned out to be very useful, and it 
turned out to be from DD...

In any case, we DO KNOW that DD is an experienced time-traveler, from 
the instructions he gave Hermione in the hospital ward near the end 
of PoA... "three turns should do it."







More information about the HPforGrownups archive