Will Neville kill Voldy?

jlnbtr jlnbtr at yahoo.com
Tue May 22 00:27:55 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 169080

Welcome Nathan! 
 
Nathan: In few words, my theory is that Voldy was wrong about HP 
being the one on the prophecy. 

Juli: You could be right, but Dumbledore clearly explains in HBP that 
Harry is indeed the 'chosen one'. LV chose Harry to be the one the 
prophesy refers to. Voldemort picked Harry and marked him (his scar) 
as his equal. As far as we know (which isn't much by the way) 
Voldemort doesn't even aknowledge Neville's existance, he's never 
made a single hit against him or his family. I am not counting his 
parents, they were tortured because of their job, in fact Jo said 
once on her website (in Rumors I think) that the Lestrange weren't 
sent to the Longbottom's house searching for Neville, they were there 
for Frank and Alice

Nathan: HP and LV discovering that HP is really a (accidental) 
Horcrux, and HP will ask some of his friends (Rony, or Hermione, or 
Ginny) to kill him as being the only way to LV become mortal. Then 
Neville kills LV. Later, the love (in a way that I do not suspect) 
brings HP back to life.

Juli: How is it possible to create an accidental Horcrux? Slughorn 
mentions to young Tom Riddle that there are some spells to be done 
other than the actual killing, so how is it possible to create an 
horcrux without saying or doing whatever needs to be done?

Harry would NEVER ask his friends to commit murder. We already know 
that killing someone breaks our soul, and the soul is the most 
precious posession of any given person, so why would he condem his 
friends to that? Sorry but I don't see it happening. Harry may 
sacrifice himself, that is a strong possibility, he is so focused on 
his goal that his life is nothing but a small price to pay to get rid 
of the menace of Voldemort.

We already know there's no way to bring anyone from the death. Jo 
told us so after she killed Sirius. A huge fan of Sirius as I am, I 
wish for nothing more than his return to book seven, but all I have 
are false hopes, I know he won't come back. As I know Harry won't 
come back if he gets killed.

Juli - returning after a long time





More information about the HPforGrownups archive