Was Ministry going to punish Snape if kills Sirius on site? WAS: On perfecti

[justcarol67]

No: HPFGUIDX 169117

Carol earilier:
> And even as it is, the kids owe him their lives for taking them to
the hospital wing when a werewolf was on the grounds.

Alla responded:
> 
> That's your opinion, Carol. Mine is that kids owe their life to 
Sirius Black if such mortal danger existed.
>

Carol:
How about owing their lives to both Snape and Black? Certainly, Black
chased the werewolf off originally, but at the time I'm speaking of,
Black was unconscious and the werewolf was still at large.

Carol, who thinks that the wish to stay out of Azkaban is sensible
rather than self-serving and wonders why it wasn't shared by Lupin,
who was quite ready to commit murder for reasons not so different from
Snape's