What makes LV so powerful?
houyhnhnm102
celizwh at intergate.com
Wed May 23 02:59:48 UTC 2007
No: HPFGUIDX 169135
Tandra:
> This has been gnawing at me since I just finished the
> 6th book yet again. I know LV hunts down power and
> finds out stuff that most other wizards don't care
> to find out, but I don't get why he was so powerful
> by the time DD met him in the orphanage. It seemed
> obvious to DD that he wasn't an ordinary wizard, but
> where did all this power come from? Because he was
> an heir of Slytherin? Is there anything that leads
> us to believe that Slytherin was all that powerful?
> I just don't see why he is all so powerful. Can
> anyone help me there?
houyhnhnm:
If magical power is inherited, it seems like it would
have suffered from the same kind of impairment from
the Gaunts' inbreeding that many of their other traits
obviously did. I would be more inclined to credit
Voldemort's half blood status with his exceptional
ability, if that is what he had. We have a lot of
examples of hybrid vigor in the series.
I think what set the eleven-year-old Tom Riddle apart,
however, was not exceptional magical ability so much
as a lack of innocence. Dumbledore said to Harry,
"His powers, as you heard, were surprisingly
well-developed for such a young wizard and--most
interestingly and ominously of all--he had already
discovered that he had some measure of control over
them, and had begun to use them consciously. And as
you saw, they were not the random experiments typical
of young wizards: He was already using magic against
other people, to frighten, to punish, to control."
I think what Dumbledore was saying was that it was Tom
Riddle's sociopathy that was precocious as much as his
magical ability. At least that's the way I see Voldemort.
I don't see him developing into this powerful evil Dark
Wizard just because he was so fantastically talented above
any one else of his generation. He may have been gifted,
but it was the amorality, absence of any normal ability
to form connections with other people, absence of normal
inhibitions and a sense of right and wrong that enabled
him to become Lord Voldemort. The ability to con people,
to use them, to hurt them, completely untrammeled by any
feelings of shame, guilt, or remorse, "talents" exhibited
by criminals with no magical ability whatsoever.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive