Snape's involvement in the murder of Sirius

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 169219

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "phoenixgod2000" <jmrazo at ...> 
wrote:
<snip>
> I will agree that Snape is more in control in this scene and not on 
> the verge of anger ant exploding, but I do't like the Snape as the 
> stronger man bit. I think that proves just how small, petty, and 
> evils Snape can be.  Sirius is an escapee from the worlds worst 
> prison, wrongfully accused, and is now locked away a second time.  
> Snape meanwhile, has lived a pretty good life, while actually being 
> a criminal, and never sent away to where he probably belongs.  
> 
> Sirius held it together for fifteen long years, held it because of 
> love for Harry and loyalty to his dead friends.  Sirius may be 
> broken (although a characterization I don't like from OOTP, it does 
> fit) but I don't think he should ever be characterized as pathetic.
> 
> Snape on the other hand...

<snip>


Alla:

Heee, sure, I buy that. But to me Snape's pettiness, evillness and 
overall, please die Snape reaction is more shown in what he does to 
Harry and Neville.

It is like how lower you can sink then to torment child whom you 
already hurt so much, you bastard. But I digress.

 I used to think that Snape and Sirius have pretty good chemistry, 
taunts and all. Never mind my mind of the slasher, heheeh.

I loved shaking hands scene in GoF ( that is where I still had hopes 
for something very different of Snape variety) and I loved this one 
as well - chemistry wise, heheh.

Not that I have any respect for Snape here of course, but it sure 
gives food for imagination, mine anyways <g>