Responses to Marietta (was: Misc. responses, some quite old)

[finwitch]

No: HPFGUIDX 169263

Bart:

> 
> That was based on the in-canon indications of Hermione's lack of 
originality in spellcasting, which makes it HIGHLY unlikely that she 
could come up with a spell that experts can't undo. Therefore we have 
it in canon that: 
> 
> A) Hermione cast the spell.
> B) Nobody HAS undone the spell.
> C) It is highly unlikely that nobody CAN undo the spell. 
> 
> Therefore, if people can, but people don't, it is likely that 
people won't.

Finwitch:

I think I can think of at least one person who *could* have, and 
would have -  undone the spell: Dumbledore. Of course, as events had 
it, Dumbledore *had* to leave, so no healing for now.

Fawkes' tears might work (but the bird won't do it).

Anyway, do you suppose Marietta has been healed by now, even though 
she wasn't mentioned again? Maybe she took to reading quietly in the 
library and found the cure (along with improving her grades).

Finwitch