favorite Harry moments?

dumbledore11214 dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Mon May 28 16:40:51 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 169392

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Sherry Gomes" <sherriola at ...> 
wrote:
>
> Ok, since I am not interested in reading about Snape favorite 
moments, and
> since the books are Harry's story, how about some favorite Harry 
moments?
> Even people who don't particularly like Harry might have some 
favorite
> moments of his.  I'll start it off by trying to pinpoint some of 
my favorite
> Harry moments.  in no particular order, by the way.


Alla:

Oooooooo, you read my mind dear, you so read my mind.



Sherry:
<SNIP>
> And possibly my two very favorite moments for Harry, back to POA, 
are Harry
> and Sirius leaving the shack and their discussion about Harry 
living with
> Sirius.  I love how he says something like, are you crazy, of 
course I want
> to live with you.  Do you have a house?  This moment always gets 
me a little
> choked up, now that I know the way that flame of hope will be 
smothered.
> And the moment later, before escaping on Buckbeak, when Sirius 
tells Harry
> he really is his father's son.  No matter what we do or don't know 
about
> James later, right then, that was a perfect beautiful thing to 
tell Harry.
> POA is really so much about Harry and his father in many ways, and 
to give
> him that validation was very special.
<SNIP>


Alla:

I love these, in fact I love everything you listed and agree with 
them, but that means I should list different ones, heheh.

I love, love, love how JKR IMO subtly showed in HBP that Harry's 
ability to love is indeed unusual.

He felt brief compassion for Tom Riddle and drop of pity for Malfoy.

Yes, yes, I know compassion for Tom Riddle was brief and went away 
right away. But to me the fact that he was **able** to feel it even 
for the shortest period of time is SO amazing. I mean amazing that 
he could feel anything positive for the man who brought so much 
misery in his life, who killed his parents, took so many loved ones 
from him, etc.

I thought JKR did a brilliant job with this, absolutely brilliant.


What else did I love? Oh, of course Graveyard. I was amazed how very 
strong he managed to be while facing the horrible torture.


I love, love how Harry grows through the books, how complex of the 
character he becomes ( angry teenager in OOP was amazing in my 
opinion - the only thing I loved about that book).

I will come back with more later :)

Thanks Sherry :)





More information about the HPforGrownups archive