Slytherin as villains / Ender vs. Harry SPOILERS for Ender's Game

Zara zgirnius at yahoo.com
Fri Nov 16 17:25:37 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 179139

> Montavilla47:
> Unless they flooed from the Hogshead, which really makes the most 
> sense of all.  In which case, Voldemort wouldn't have seen *any*
> students, unless the students made a point of leaving the Hogshead
> by the door--going directly into the Death Eater camp (in 
> Hogsmeade).  At which point, Voldemort might have patted them
> on  the head and sent them home, or given the older ones masks,
> or set them to non-combat tasks, like gathering wood for their
> fire, cleaning up the Shrieking Shack, etc.

zgirnius:
And in the case of some of those children (Theo Nott comes to mind, 
sorry, Potioncat), Flooing home would be pointless. Papa Nott is in 
the Forest, one presumes, and Mama Nott is long dead. 

Montavilla:
> Incidently, Aberforth seems to think that the Slytherin students are
> all the children of Death Eaters, since he criticizes the Dumbledore
> forces for not keeping them all hostage.

zgirnius:
No, he thinks that *some* of them are. (At least one, Theo Nott, is 
known to be by us as well). "There are kids of Death Eaters you've 
just sent to safety" means there are some kids who are kids of Death 
Eaters, not that all the kids are. He also does not suggest all the 
Slytherins shiyld have been held hostage, just 'a few'. (Presumably, 
the few who are kids of Death Eaters, since why anyone in the DE camp 
would care about the others is not clear to me).







More information about the HPforGrownups archive