[HPforGrownups] Snape's protection (was Re: Another thing (was JKR, the female and facism)

[Kemper]

No: HPFGUIDX 179184

>  Potioncat:
>  We know that terrible things happened under the Carrows' influence.
>  But we also know that Luna wasn't taken from Hogwarts, she was
>  snatched off the train. And Ginny wasn't allowed to leave Hogwarts to
>  go to Hogsmeade. We know it was full of DEs. So, Snape seems to have
>  been able to protect those under his roof to some extent. Although,
>  if LV had asked for Trelawney, I think Snape would have given her up.


Kemper now:
Instead of giving her up, maybe he would have had her killed gently
with a brew of some delicious concoction with a spring of mint or
fresh ground nutmeg.

Kemper