[HPforGrownups] Re: Which characters knew DD was Gay?

[Kemper]

No: HPFGUIDX 179224

> > "Hagrid" <aussie_lol@> wrote:
>  > [huge snip]
>  > > What about others? -and would that change how we view the
>  > > story? ... Mad-eye Moody, McGonagall, Tom Riddle (Slughorn in
>  > > HBP said Tom had a way of finding out information), Slughorn,
>
>  > > Snape, Hagrid, Mdm Pomfrey (allowing DD to sit with unconscious
>  > > Harry in PS/SS), Fudge, and also ... did the Chocolate Frog
>  > > Card writers know?
>  >
>  > Shaunette now:
>  >
>  > Are you saying that a gay Dumbledore should not be left alone
>  > with an unconscious Harry, but a straight one alone with him
>  > would be fine? That Mdm Pomfrey would (or should) take this into
>  > account (if she knew)?
>
>  Susan:
>
>  Hmmmm..given that the vast majority of child rapists/child molesters
>  are men molesting girls...if DD were STRAIGHT, then he probably
>  shouldn't have been allowed to sit with unconscious Hermione? Hmmm?
>  Is that the argument?

Kemper now:
Perhaps what that poster (they didn't say who they were) was
attempting to show --though admittedly not clearly-- that Mdm Pomfrey
as a reflection of the WW feels that it is no big deal that DD was
gay.

Kemper, offering alternate views of reading a post