[HPforGrownups] Hallows (was: Re: Dumbledore - Good as Written?)

[Lynda Cordova]

No: HPFGUIDX 179386

a_svirn:

in PS Ron, who had never seen an Invisible Cloak before had no difficulty in

recognizing it and said that they are "rare".

Lynda:

But nothing that is said in DH disputes that. In fact, it is confirmed when
the trio discusses it after talking to Lovegood.  What Harry has is an
invisibility cloak that is apparently indestructable, unlike others on which
the disillusionment charm wears off after awhile or one that is made of the
fur of a magical creature from which the concealment also evaporates
eventually, so Ron was correct in calling them rare, and that *does* leave
an opening for Harry's cloak to be different than the others because it
comes from a different source.

Lynda


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]