Harry, impossible to kill?

ANGIE plantladywithcfids at yahoo.ca
Fri Oct 5 04:37:46 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 177739


> > ANGIE wrote:
>
> > So here is my theory.
> > When Harry chose to go to his death to end it all and Voldemort
> > used the AK curse the Elder wand recognised its true master and
> > did not send a full powered curse at Harry refusing to kill its
> > true master.   <SNIP>
>
> zanooda:
>
> I very much agree that many things must be considered here, but I'm
> kind of reluctant to include the Elder wand into this. When the
> wand recognized Harry during the last confrontation, it threw LV's
> curse back at him, that's how it protected it's master.
> <snip>

angie:
Yes but in the last confrontation Harry was "armed" with Draco's wand
and was defending himself with it against Voldemort. The elder wand
again recognised its true master and this time could react because
its master was reacting.  The Expelliarmus spell Harry sent out is
what actually caused the elder wand to reflect the spell back at
Voldemort and this time it could protect its master 100%.

In the forest Harry did nothing to defend himself and therefore the
elder wand could not react against anything and had to do, all be it
half heartedly and with less power, what the "master" holding it told
it to do.

Harry could have died if he had chosen to "go on" and catch a train
but he chose to return and end it all bringing Voldemort back with
him like the prophecy says...one can not survive etc.....If Harry had
chosen to "go on" I think Voldemort would have had to use the horcrux
inside Nagini to return.






More information about the HPforGrownups archive