Slytherin quote sourced! was Villain!Dumbledore (was: re:HatingDH/Dementors

[pippin_999]

No: HPFGUIDX 177810


> >Pippin:
> >Somebody may have picked up a Quick Quotes Quill by mistake <g>.
> 
> lizzyben:
> 
> Since I posted that, I thought I should include the link:
> 
<snip quote>"
> 
> http://groups.yahoo.com/group/HPforGrownups/message/100012
> 
> This is from a HPfGU post; I can't confirm or deny it beyond that. But
> it does seem consistent w/her other quote about being "concerned" that
> some people self-identify as Slytherins. 

Pippin:
Thanks Lizzyben!

A little sleuthing shows that a fansite award and link to the 
Godric's Hollow website was removed on May 13th 2006 
because the GH site no longer existed in its original form
(according to the HP-lexicon.)  The quote according to p. 31
of the "Unauthorized "Half-Blood Prince" Update" by W. Frederick
Zimmerman was: A great site run by real enthusiasts. The 
people who designed this site have really Thought It Through--
my kind of people. I am however shocked at the number of
moderators who want to be sorted into Slytherin...and you 
should know that the Hufflepuff's common room isn't a
dungeon. It's more a cellar - a subtle but important difference.

You can find the whole book on Google book search. 

Anyway, like the other quote it sounds like teasing 
since she is  praising the site and its moderators
and linking to it from her site.  I can find no Google
or accio results that Rowling has ever used the phrase 
"shocked and disturbed."

Pippin
having a LOON moment (League of Overly Obsessed Nitpickers)