[HPforGrownups] 3 questions about The Deathly Hallows

patricia bindrim peppermintpattie4 at yahoo.com
Thu Oct 11 20:38:25 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 177901

--- johnson_fan4evre48 <johnson_fan4evre48 at yahoo.com>
wrote:

> Q. 1.In it, it describes the life and lies of
> Dumbledore, Is Ms. Rowling
> trying to show the Mr. Dumbledore was not perfect or
> was she trying to
> show all the mistakes he had done and did not
> realize them til it was
> too late, along the lines you learn from your
> mistakes.
> 
> Q.2.  We see the full reaches of Lord Voldemort's
> power. Technically did
> he use peoples fear of his name or the knowledge
> that Harry was not
> scared of his name to track down those who were
> against him, and to find
> Harry?
> 
> Q.3. When Harry went to the Godric Hollow to Lily
> and James's
> gravesite, and he found out it was yet another thing
> that Dumbledore
> left out, do you feel it was what drove him to find
> out about the
> Horcruxes or to find out who he Harry really was?

peppermintpattie:

In my opinion to Q. 1, I think Dumbledore was not perfect and did not want to burden Harry with all details of Dumbledores life.

My answer to Q. 2, Yes I believe Voldemort used his power and other people's fear of him to help track down Harry and others who oppose him.

My answer to Q. 3, In my opinion when Harry realized that Dumbledore did not tell everything about where he came from, he was not deceiving Harry with non important stuff but to help Harry with more inportant information that will be helpful in defeating Voldemort.





More information about the HPforGrownups archive