Could Harry have saved Snape? (was Reacting to DH...)

[Tiffany B. Clark]

No: HPFGUIDX 178041

Ceridwen:

Hermione sank below the sub-sub-basement for me here.  Miss Level-
headed in a Crisis, and all she can do is conjure a phial?  Sorry.  
She was level-headed enough to bounce-Apparate when Yaxley grabbed 
onto her after leaving the MoM, she could have remembered her 
carefully-planned store of dittany.  Instead, she came off as 
Redshirt number two, giving Kirk whatever he needs, with far less 
effective results.
 
Tiffany:

Hermione has some moments of sheer brilliance & being a good heroine, 
but most of the time she seems to not have some of them also.  I loved 
how she was able to hold her own in SS & have some good moments, but 
after then most of her ideas weren't the most well-developed & thought 
out around.  Her ideas & use of spells after leaving MoM was nothing 
short of sheer brilliance on her part, but those are few & far between 
for her.