Things not overtly mentioned in canon. (was: I am so happy.)

Valerie Frankel valerie at calithwain.com
Sat Oct 20 20:43:14 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 178149

I think all the extra info that never made it into the books is 
interesting but a little perplexing-- there's the books, which we love, 
and there are these random facts with so little proof or linkage in the 
text that they feel like fanfic. As far as Dumbledore's closet, I did 
find it interesting back when I was reading that while he "fathers" 
Harry, and even Snape and James and Draco a bit, we see no evidence of 
a wife/old girlfriend/child in D's past. His closest relationships 
(and, granted, most major HP characters) seem to be male. It adds a 
level of complexity and depth that Dumbledore isn't just destroying his 
best friend to end the wizarding world's side of WWII, but someone with 
a deeper relationship-- in a series this caught up in the meaning and 
consequences of love, I think it does add something to find out how 
Dumbledore's love affected him...on the other hand, we don't find out 
much, do we? It's rather a cheat that there's no allusion to any of 
this within the series.

Valerie Frankel
author of Henry Potty and the Pet Rock
An Unauthorized Harry Potter Parody 





More information about the HPforGrownups archive