Other New News

johnson_fan4evre48 johnson_fan4evre48 at yahoo.com
Sun Oct 21 22:44:55 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 178213

Prep0strus:
> > <snip>... - professor, caretaker, auror, ministry official,... thief.

>  va32h:
> > Well I concluded a long time ago that the whole "planned in detail
> > for 17 years" was nothing but a fan-enhanced myth.

> Mike:
> <snip> I find no value in anything she hasn't written in
> the books...

> > va32h
> > I hope she never writes that dang encyclopedia...

> Mike:
> OK, I'll say it: Ms Rowling, could you please follow Mr. Twain's
> advice and cease speaking up to remove all doubt?!

I snipped out as much as I dare so you all can understand my thought. I
honestly thought I was the only one to see how things had been left out
or full stories were not completely thought out.

I must re-read Deathly Hallows because her thought left me confused, and
then I see where your  statements had left me thinking, I was not the
only one to see how it was sort of a let down when you hold it up to her
other books.

Amanda




More information about the HPforGrownups archive