[HPforGrownups] Re: Other New News

[Vincent Maston]

No: HPFGUIDX 178261

Bart Lidofsky a crit :
> 2) It was too easy to see through it. Now, I could understand if DD could detect presence through sound (heartbeats, or whatever), but when MadEye's eye could see right through it, it lowers its power well below the other DH's. 

Vincent :

Not really, no.
The DH are not described as "perfect" objetc, they have their flaws, and 
are just really (really really) well made, but still classical, magical 
objects.

The Elder wand is a real good wand, like you could have a real good pair 
of shoes. But even with real good shoes, you still can be beat by a 
faster runner, and the Elder Wand is by no means unbeatable, whatever 
DD, Grindelwald or Voldy all believe at one time or another.

The cloak, I think, is the same thing : it's a real good invisibility 
cloak, not fading or becoming seeable, but if someone (DD, MadEye) can 
see through a cloak, he'll be able to see through this cloak. It doesn't 
have any powers that an invisibility cloak doesn't have. Only better.

And the stone... Don't get me started about the stone...