Warriors (was: The problems with DD being gay)

lizzyben04 lizzyben04 at yahoo.com
Mon Oct 22 18:19:22 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 178273

<snip>
> va32h:
>
> But why would Gellert do that? Why would he voluntarily give up
his
> power and let himself be imprisoned just because his old pal
> Dumbledore asked him to?
>
> My interpretation of Rita's comments was that the duel was not a
> "duel" per se but Dumbledore fighting dirty, using such cruel and
> heinous methods that Grindelwald was forced to surrender.
>
> va32h


lizzyben:

There's obviously more to the story here (hey, fan fiction!) I've
always wondered why we never heard about how DD defeated GG. At
first everyone thought he killed him, then it's revealed that GG is
still alive. (Yes, possible Flint, but go with me here) How could DD
ever get a Dark Wizard to go to prison quietly? How could he defeat
a wizard in a duel when that wizard had the "unbeatable" Elder Wand?
However DD eventually defeated GG, I don't think it involved a duel.


lizzyben








More information about the HPforGrownups archive