JKR messed up........ no.

[Miles]

No: HPFGUIDX 178497

delwynmarch wrote:
> Miles wrote:
>> Anyone should feel free to act as they were created or made or
>> became, with the limitations we all have to face.
>
> Del replies:
> Then should LV feel free to act as he was created?
> Should Draco feel free to act as he was raised/became?
> Should the wizards feel free to take over the Muggles since they
> *are* objectively stronger than them?

Miles:
If you compare homosexuals to pathological killers, I do not see a point in
any further discussion. You might just try to reread my statement you
quoted, though, and might understand it.

delwynmarch wrote:
> Miles:
>> Sure, without any school diploma or job qualification, they could
>> just return to the muggle world.
>
> They wouldn't be the first ones to face such conditions. Most
> emigrants are in that situation, except much worse because they often
> have no family to help them and they often don't even speak the
> language.

> Miles:
>> There still is a social security system in Britain, so they would
>> not starve.
>
> Precisely.

Miles:
Well, next time I will insert sarcasm tags.

I do not like to compare anything to Nazi crimes, but what we read about the
treatment of muggleborns in DH is very similar to the treatment of German
Jews before the war. They lost their jobs and were forbidden to work in
their profession. They were expropriated, many had to give up their entire
fortune to leave the country. Others stayed in Germany, because it was their
home. As many muggleborns, who stayed in *their* home world, these Jews had
problems to make their living without a job, there might have been
situations not too different to the one we saw in Diagon Alley.

Now, you stick with your argument? I doubt, looking down at homosexuals
might be considered ok within some groups in our world, but to kick the
victims of the pre-Holocaust German Jew prosecution is a taboo... But I must
admit that I never expected anyone would blame the fictional victims of Lord
Voldemorts regime for their fate just for the sake of sticking to a
homophobic pov, but I had to learn a lesson.

Miles