A sandwich

[eggplant107]

No: HPFGUIDX 178631

 "Katie" <anigrrrl2 at ...> wrote:

> I'm someone who is deeply disturbed
> by Harry's final remark

Wow, so that sandwich not only disturbed you it DEEPLY disturbed you.
You disturb easy. 

> regarding Kreacher, and I am in no
> way attempting to be "provocative".  

Don't be so defensive, everybody wants to be provocative and there's
nothing wrong with that. Why do you thing authors write books trying
to show what you thought was true is not, that the man generally
regarded as a hero was really a villain and the man everybody thought
a villain was really a nice man? 
I believe this is also the reason that in every Potter discussion
group I've ever seen Harry and Hermione can do no good and Snape can
do no wrong. Being provocative is good but you need more to work with
than a sandwich. 

> I would *hope* that Harry would never
> use Kreacher as a servant  

That would be just about as cruel a thing Harry could possibly do. I
seem to remember something similar happened to Winkey and she went
into a bit of a decline.

> Poor Kreacher deserves a rest. 

And Harry didn't?! After he killed Voldemort the relieved wizards
would have probably made Harry the king of the entire wizard world if
he asked for the job, but he didn't, all Harry asked for is a
sandwich.  And you were shocked, shocked I tell you, at this
unreasonable request. You think after the bloody Battle of Hogwarts
all the survivors should have turned to Harry as one and shouted at
the man who had just saved their life "Get your own damn sandwich Potter!"
   
> I don't think it's silly 

Come on, be honest, not even a little?

Eggplant