Imperio

[raven_paul_07]

No: HPFGUIDX 176931

> > > Laura:
> > > By that reasoning, Hermione's modification of her parents
> > > memories is also Unforgiveable. She does it with the best
> > > of intentions, but she doesn't give them a choice
<SNIP>

> > Bruce Alan Wilson:
> > How do we know that she gave them no choice in the matter?
> > She may have sat them down and given them a complete breakdown
> > of the situation and her proposed course of action
<SNIP>

> Laura:
> But, as interested in knowing everything as Hermione is, it
> seems odd to me that her parents would choose to NOT know
> something. Hermione is in the house that is known for courage,
> too.
<SNIP>


raven_paul_07:

I agree. Hermione is bright. She has a lot of knowledge but not
so much wisdom. What she showed is selfishness. She wants to go
with Harry and Ron to find the other Horcruxes - she had a point
on that one. But she chose to leave her parents not knowing where
she would go. My professor says, "Parents would understand if you
would explain it very well. You cannot blame them because they
always worry about you..." Hermione is such a bright witch, I
hoped that she would know that. She can always explain it to
her parents in a proper manner but did not do it because of
selfishness. She always thought that she can handle all things
in her hand.